Topic on User talk:Bovlb

Jump to navigation Jump to search
ZeusAmmon1 (talkcontribs)

Hi Bovb, can you be more spesific about my deleted contribition? Which part didn't appear constructive to you? The terms i have used is always used by EU , USA and of course Turkey, the country most affected by these terror attacks.

Bovlb (talkcontribs)

Of course. Glad to help. Some points about your changes:

  1. Help:Description#Avoid_controversial_claims says you should avoid including controversial claims in descriptions. PKK is not described as a "terrorist organization" in its description, so adding that elsewhere makes it seem like you are trying to push some specific point. In general, a statement on Kurdistan Workers' Party (Q152220) is the correct place for such a claim, where it can be given with supporting evidence, and qualified as appropriate with statement supported by (P3680) and statement disputed by (P1310). We should not be inserting a disputable claim like this into descriptions, especially on other items.
  2. Help:Description#Capitalization says that descriptions begin with a lowercase letter except when uppercase would normally be required or expected.
  3. In Wikidata, humans are generally instance of (P31) merely of human (Q5). Gender, occupation, position held, etc. all have their own more specific properties.
  4. A claim like occupation (P106) terrorist (Q14886050) would require references.
  5. The property perpetrator (P8031) is used to relate a specific event to the person or organization who perpetrated it. It should not be used to qualify a statement, and the object should not be a class of events.

I hope this helps!