Topic on User talk:ChristianKl/Structured Discussions Archive 1

Hello ChristianKl,

I don't really understand which description I should to add. Can you help please.

The description currently contains content that's a template. {{Q|XXX}} is a template. That template get's rendered in the Wiki view in which the proposal happens to be but it doesn't get rendered in the actual description of a property once it's created.

This was the description before i have changed it:

National Library of Israel (Q188915) (NLI) for a bibliographic record: a specific edition (Q3331189) of a book or other publications in the National Library of Israel Online Catalog (NNL).

And this is the descrption for P1144 which is quiet similar:

Library of Congress Control Number (Q620946) (LCCN) for a bibliographic record: a specific edition (Q3331189) of a book or other publications in the U.S. Library of Congress Online Catalog (LCOC).

I get your point. I opened Wikidata:Project chat#Should the description in the proposal documentation match the description of the property.3F to have a more open discussion about how the description should look like.

The current answer agrees with my opinion that P1144 shouldn't have a separate description on the property talk page than it has as the property description. The property talk page can format Wikitext but the core description can't.

Wikidata:Property proposal/NLI NNL (bibliographic) description was modified by User:ArthurPSmith. Is it ok now?

Yes, I created it.

Thanks