Hello, would you please revert such edits?
Topic on User talk:Bodhisattwa
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
The continent (P30) is used for countries only, not at the level of cities, towns, where country (P17) and located in the administrative territorial entity (P131) describes the location. Isn't it? It would be kind of redundant to put continent (P30) at all level of geographical entities.
No. There are multi-continent countries where P17 doesn't imply continent.
And there can be even cities (or may be even smaller places) which belong to 2 continents simultaneuosly.
It is quite redundant to put the continent P30 at all levels of geographical entities. In cases of multi-continent countries or cities, it makes complete sense to tag P30, but in places where there is confirmed single-value continent, it makes no sense. In these cases, P30 can be retrieved going to higher levels. In this particular case of Delhi -> country (P17) India has continent P30.
what if in one time the city was in division A in one continent, and in other time the same city was in division B in the other continent? (My city is the example)