The de-wiki and en-wiki articles are both surname articles, with identical content.
Topic on User talk:ValterVB
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
They aren't the same: the page in de.wiki is a real disambiguation page and you can find it in de:Spezial:Begriffsklärungsseiten, the page in en.wiki, instead, is a page about the surname, it's fall under "set index articles" and you can't find it in en:Special:DisambiguationPages. In a disambiguation page it's important only the spelling, in a page about surname you can talk only about surname. See the special case of our guideline.
De:Bindrich's content is as follows: "Bindrich ist der Familienname folgender Personen:" Emphasis on "Familienname".
It is an error on de-wiki. It should be under Kategorie:Familienname.
We can wait that de.wiki fix the problem, otherwise the BOTs continue to make mistakes.