Talk:Q23543

From Wikidata
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Image[edit]

Hello. TheBellaTwins1445 has repeatedly tried to add Selena Drawing by Elioth.png, image uploaded and created by him (see Facebook link in Commons description). But I think that image is not good enough, and does not have the best quality. Also, I think that the user should not try to impose his own art, as he has tried to do in other wikipedias, e.g. cbk-zam, crh, gl, sl, es, etc.

I think it would be better to add another, for example, Selena drawing.jpg (current) or maybe Selena's tombstone. ¿Sugestions? --Gusama Romero </talk> 01:19, 22 December 2017 (UTC)[reply]

Hi, re-opening the discussion five years later, I have never tried to add my drawing/image, its just that is the only file that can currently be used to represent Selena, not a copyvio from a graffiti or something else, is just an image that can be used to represent her meanwhile since there are none photographs of her on Commons. There is another drawing and a graffiti which are the following:

The first one could of be taken as a random illustration of a woman since it has not color or trail to represent Selena on it, and the second one is a graffiti that do not even looks like her. Which take us to this one that, yes indeed was made by me, but I have never tried to imposed it, its just that at this point is the last one left out of the three that could of be chosen to represent her and fits her well with the purple jumpsuit and the Mexican-American stuff. Would like to hear more voices out there regarding this current situation. Greetings. TheBellaTwins1445 (talk) 23:38, 11 January 2022 (UTC)[reply]

I said it before, the drawing is not good enough nor does it have good quality, and also, I agree that it is not representative. I understand that there is no other image available, but it is not mandatory to have one. I like the mural version better, but it doesn't have much quality either; I wouldn't use any.--Gusama Romero </talk> 02:15, 15 January 2022 (UTC)[reply]