Wikidata:Interwiki conflicts/Unresolved/2018
|
January 2018[edit]
Potato[edit]
Items involved: Q10998Talk, Q16587531Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Almost all pages should point to the food, potato (Q16587531), but right now most large languages point to the species (Q10998). Sj (talk) 19:44, 24 January 2018 (UTC) |
Food additives[edit]
Items involved: Q2596997Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Probably should be separated: ru:Вкусовые добавки includes salt, and ro:Condiment not. --Infovarius (talk) 20:32, 1 January 2018 (UTC) |
varicose veins (Q201180)/varices (Q2624485)[edit]
Items involved: Q201180Talk, Q2624485Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Q201180 may be about "leg varices" or a more general notion of varices. Maybe Q5296227 should be considered too. --Ske (talk) 08:50, 3 January 2018 (UTC) |
thoroughfare (Q83620)/transport route (Q1297806)[edit]
Items involved: Q83620Talk, Q1297806Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
To an English speaker these appear to be the same concept at first, but I am unsufficiently familiar with German to understand the difference between Transportweg and Verkehrsweg. — Ipoellet (talk) 20:07, 5 January 2018 (UTC)
|
logogram (Q138659)/logographic writing system (Q3953107)[edit]
Items involved: Q138659Talk, Q3953107Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
--Coobit (talk) 08:17, 15 January 2018 (UTC)
|
subscription business model (Q43006303)/subscription business model (Q322948)/subscription business model (Q4054833)[edit]
Items involved: Q43006303Talk, Q322948Talk, Q4054833Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Hi! en:Subscription (finance) should not be at Q322948, en:Subscription business model should be there instead. The description (in English) is also wrong. Most other languages in Q322948 that I can tell point to the business model, not the financial term. --Jfsamper (talk) 02:46, 17 January 2018 (UTC) |
low spot (Q22978151)/depression (Q190429)[edit]
Items involved: Q22978151Talk, Q190429Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
This appears to be the same thing.--Shisma (talk) 19:30, 31 January 2018 (UTC)
|
February 2018[edit]
Jonah (Q2468262)/Yunus (Q18811437)/Jonah in rabbinic literature (Q16158490)[edit]
Items involved: Q2468262Talk, Q18811437Talk, Q16158490Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
They are about the same prophet. I don't know why the latter is assigned to Islam snice the articles are general and explain about him in different religions.Gharibi6 (talk) 10:57, 13 February 2018 (UTC)
Jonah (Q2468262) is explained about Yunus from general perspective include Jews, Christian, and Islam perspective. While Yunus (Q18811437), only explained about Yunus from Islam perspective.Ilham151096 (talk) 10:26, 24 May 2018 (UTC) |
load line mark (Q942969)/standard state (Q1878074)/waterline (Q492878)[edit]
Items involved: Q1878074Talk, Q942969Talk, Q492878Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
According to the English article, the Dutch articles should be swapped, but I don't know about the other languages. Is there someone with more knowledge about ships and terms? Q.Zanden questions? 19:21, 15 February 2018 (UTC) |
Manito Park and Botanical Gardens (Q9055827)/Manito Park (Q49596988)[edit]
Items involved: Q9055827Talk, Q49596988Talk | Status: partially resolved | ||
Are ceb:Manito Park (parke) and ceb:Manito Park (patag) just two redundant articles on the Cebuano Wikipedia? If so, these two items should be merged, but which Cebuano article to include in the sitelinks? — Ipoellet (talk) 20:27, 24 February 2018 (UTC)
|
March 2018[edit]
Category:Parts of speech (Q7216841)/Category:Lemmas by word class (Q30747696)[edit]
Items involved: Q7216841Talk, Q30747696Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
--Naggy Nagumo (talk) 04:54, 9 March 2018 (UTC)
|
Mona Passage (Q1418401)/Mona Passage (Q23764901)/Mona Passage (Q34972544)[edit]
Items involved: Q1418401Talk, Q23764901Talk, Q34972544Talk | Status: partially resolved | ||
These all relate to the same body of water. Items have proliferated due to redundant cebwiki articles (ceb:Mona Passage (agianan) and ceb:Mona Passage (agianan nga kadagatan), related to redundant GeoNames entries) and redundant svwiki articles (sv:Mona Passage (havskanal) and sv:Monapassagen). The items need to be merged, but I suppose we need to have the Wikipedias merge their articles first. — Ipoellet (talk) 19:31, 20 March 2018 (UTC)
|
Stark and weak verbs[edit]
Items involved: Q4129241Talk, Q60655Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
--Matěj Suchánek (talk) 18:21, 21 March 2018 (UTC)
|
Q6094100/quart (Q1058120)[edit]
Items involved: Q6094100Talk, Q1058120Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
Somehow this should be resolved differently. eswiki doesn't have any permanent duplicates as it includes only one page on a topic. The sitelinks seems to be about "quart" in different languages and times. Somehow this should be split per region/period. --
|
BMC ADO17 (Q266681)/BMC ADO17 (Q26257523)[edit]
Items involved: Q266681Talk, Q26257523Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Somehow this should be sorted differently, probably by model designation. dewiki shouldn't have any "permanent" duplicates. --
|
April 2018[edit]
quadrupedalism (Q21907045)/quadruped (Q777371)[edit]
Items involved: Q21907045Talk, Q777371Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
All pages shoud point to Q21907045 but impossible to merge. --[[Utilisateur:Salsero35 |Salsero35 ]]<sup class="exposant"><big><font color="#000080"> [[Discussion Utilisateur:Salsero35|✍]] </font></big> </sup> (talk) 15:51, 25 April 2018 (UTC)
|
foreign worker (Q10512400)/gastarbeiter (Q644903)[edit]
Items involved: Q10512400Talk, Q644903Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Discussion is laid out at Talk:Q10512400#Wikidata ontologic problem whereby *no* relevant German Wikipedia article can be linked from en:foreign worker in Languages nav pane. --Quercus solaris (talk) 16:03, 29 April 2018 (UTC) |
May 2018[edit]
living streets across the world[edit]
Items involved: Q814289Talk, Q1628979Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Yogyakarta (Q7568)/Kota Yogyakarta (Q24824434)[edit]
Items involved: Q7568Talk, Q24824434Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
Duplicates Ilham151096 (talk) 09:59, 24 May 2018 (UTC)
|
Māori language revival (Q493511)[edit]
Items involved: Q493511Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Five iw links, of which the en-wiki and ru-wiki pertain to one concept (revitalization of the Māori language) and the other three refer to the Maori language nest only, not the whole revitalization movement. --Yupik (talk) 23:55, 26 May 2018 (UTC) |
Maizena (Q10575468)/corn starch (Q3393961)[edit]
Items involved: Q10575468Talk, Q3393961Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
The corn_starch item includes Maicena as a spanish translation, even though it is technically a brand of corn starch. Also this brand of corn starch is the object of another item, Maizena, which contains only three languages. The French wiki doesn't have a page corresponding to corn starch but sv wiki has both pages (the making the merge non-trivial). Since I am rather a wiki-newbie I'd like someone to have a look and tell what would be the best strategy to get useful links. --CrocodilienAnonyme (talk) 21:35, 27 May 2018 (UTC)
|
June 2018[edit]
Vir (Q16104232)/VIR (Q350494)[edit]
Items involved: Q16104232Talk, Q350494Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
VIR vs. Vir disambiguation pages: 2 fr-wiki articles impedes the merge. --ŠJů (talk) 19:58, 1 June 2018 (UTC)
|
Église (Q15904453)/Kirche (Q15823565)[edit]
Items involved: Q15904453Talk, Q15823565Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Both Objects are a church --Tidoni (talk) 13:39, 7 June 2018 (UTC) |
Q233403/Godfather (Q19284238)[edit]
Items involved: Q233403Talk, Q19284238Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
The two item are disambiguation pages. They are talking about the same thing in most languages except a few like de. --Lewix (talk) 09:55, 8 June 2018 (UTC) |
Category:Bellfounders (Q9041997)/Category:Bell foundries (Q8296976)[edit]
Items involved: Q9041997Talk, Q8296976Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
if there is any distinction, the iw links seem to be a bit confused. --ŠJů (talk) 23:04, 10 June 2018 (UTC)
|
freight transport (Q651658)/cargo (Q319224)[edit]
Items involved: Q651658Talk, Q319224Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
I have fixed to some extent, but may need more work. freight transport (Q651658) is the process/activity, and cargo (Q319224) is the tangible cargo. Danrok (talk) 15:03, 12 June 2018 (UTC) |
Ajanta Caves[edit]
Items involved: Q184427Talk, Q1265645Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
UNESCO heritage vs. settlement mixed. --Matěj Suchánek (talk) 13:54, 18 June 2018 (UTC) |
business activity (Q19862406)/business (Q4830453)[edit]
Items involved: Q19862406Talk, Q4830453Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
business (Q4830453) is a duplicate of business activity (Q19862406), but at the moment they can not be merged because of five non-consistent interwiki (ht, nl, pt, sv, zh_min_nan). NB: the concept of "business" should not be confused with other different item:
|
July 2018[edit]
abandoned village (Q350895)[edit]
Items involved: Q350895Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
Needs to be split into at least 2 items by someone who speak German and English. --Danrok (talk) 13:13, 6 July 2018 (UTC)
|
Category:Heraldic figures (Q6242015)/Category:Heraldic charges (Q9660604)[edit]
Items involved: Q6242015Talk, Q9660604Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
I don't know why these categories should be separated. When looking at those languages where there is one category in each, my impression is that they could be merged. --E.G. (talk) 12:02, 20 July 2018 (UTC)
|
propast (Q55716487)/pit cave (Q1435994)/pitch (Q2631696)[edit]
Items involved: Q55716487Talk, Q1435994Talk, Q2631696Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Interwikis and descriptions are a bit confused for the three items. --ŠJů (talk) 00:24, 23 July 2018 (UTC) |
Dark Souls (Q1166232)/Dark Souls: Remastered (Q55728812)[edit]
Items involved: Q1166232Talk, Q55728812Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
Dark Souls: Remastered is a separate entity from Dark Souls, although it is its remake. On English Wikipedia, there is only the article en:Dark Souls with a section dedicated to the remaster.--Biexx (talk) 22:59, 23 July 2018 (UTC)
|
Help:Getting started (Q8990577)/Help:Introduction (Q3945)[edit]
Items involved: Q8990577Talk, Q3945Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
--Dvorapa (talk) 18:37, 27 July 2018 (UTC)
|
August 2018[edit]
Blekinge County (Q102377)/Blekinge (Q675653)[edit]
Items involved: Q102377Talk, Q675653Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
The area of the historical province is identical with the current county. Some languages (and Commons) have a common article (category) for both the province and the county. Interwikis seem to be a bit confused. Shouldn't we have 3 items: 1) for the province, 2) for the county, 3) for an integrated item about both together? --ŠJů (talk) 08:17, 8 August 2018 (UTC) |
information privacy (Q456632)/Q1295987[edit]
Items involved: Q456632Talk, Q1295987Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
My hungarian is bad. But a/t google translate this item refers to the protection of personal data. Pro: The article is part of infobox (Q15515987). human rights (Q8458) Con: The Article refers a lot to Constitution of Hungary (Q280654). IMHO it is not different enough for constituting a unique right like Informational self-determination (Q895581) especially since there are no Hungarian Interwiki links for information privacy (Q456632) --Bcoh (talk) 22:19, 11 August 2018 (UTC)
|
constructing (Q329637)/construction (Q385378)/projecting (Q1462272)/construction (Q11504411)/works (Q24897655)[edit]
Items involved: Q329637Talk, Q385378Talk, Q1462272Talk, Q11504411Talk, Q24897655Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
The difference between these two items seems to ride on the distinction between two concepts on jawiki. Can anyone elucidate this distinction? — Ipoellet (talk) 19:01, 16 August 2018 (UTC)
|
September 2018[edit]
Category:Turkish people (Q7031845)/Category:People of Turkey (Q9077925)[edit]
Items involved: Q7031845Talk, Q9077925Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Said to be the same --Jumpy01 (talk) 15:06, 2 September 2018 (UTC)
|
Government of Canada Building (Q5589191)[edit]
Items involved: Q5589191Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
There is a category of the same name on Commons, but it won't link to the Wikidata item. The English wiki article links to a general article for the City of Toronto on the French wiki, which is an error. It should point to a red link on the French wiki, and to the Commons category. I can't seem to fix this. Government_of_Canada_Building,_North_York on EN wiki and Category:Joseph_Shepard_Building on CommonsOaktree b (talk) 01:18, 5 September 2018 (UTC) |
Computer game vs video game[edit]
Items involved: Q7889Talk, Q56312618Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Computer games can include audio games, text games (which has no video interface) and others while video games can include game automats (which are not computer programs). Separation would include moving some sitelinks, some claims, some labels and some descriptions. --Infovarius (talk) 13:51, 6 September 2018 (UTC) --Infovarius (talk) 13:51, 6 September 2018 (UTC) |
Solar Hijri calendar (Q950135)/Iranian calendar (Q180311)[edit]
Items involved: Q950135Talk, Q180311Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
There are a lot of incorrect wiki links here. For instance, the fr wiki article Calendrier Persan is about the Solar Hijri calendar exclusively, whereas the en wiki Persian Calendars article includes other historical calendars, and they're both on the same item. However I suspect a large number of these articles currently linked to the "multiple calendars" item on with the en wiki article are actually about the Solar one so it might be easier to do the merge the other way around. I'm going to start working on it but thought I'd put a notice here as I might not finish. Mvolz (talk) 10:23, 7 September 2018 (UTC)
|
print (Q11060274)/printmaking (Q271588)[edit]
Items involved: Q11060274Talk, Q271588Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
While not exactly a conflict, I've moved a number of sitelinks over from print (Q11060274) to printmaking (Q271588) for the languages that I could understand enough. The remaining ones at print (Q11060274) might have to be looked at to see if they shouldn't be moved as well. Thanks! --Azertus (talk) 11:16, 11 September 2018 (UTC) |
Category:Holiday centres by country (Q10258469)/Category:Resorts by country (Q8657316)/Category:Spa towns by country (Q28031348)[edit]
Items involved: Q10258469Talk, Q8657316Talk, Q28031348Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Q10258469 is a separate item for Czech and Slovak categories of "recreational centres". Holiday (recreational) centres should be equivalent of Resorts (as redirected at en:wiki), but Q8657316 mixes holiday resorts with spa resorts, while Q28031348 mixes spa resorts with spa towns. --ŠJů (talk) 01:18, 15 September 2018 (UTC) |
Guayanilla barrio-pueblo (Q1827252)/Guayanilla barrio-pueblo (Q33677837)[edit]
Items involved: Q1827252Talk, Q33677837Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
It's not clear to me whether Guayanilla barrio-pueblo (Q33677837) refers to the settlement that is the seat of local government, or the building (town hall, casa alcaldía). If it is the settlement, then the two cebwiki articles need to be merged as well as the two wd items. If it's the building, then Q33677837 can stand with appropriate descriptions added. — Ipoellet (talk) 03:02, 16 September 2018 (UTC) |
bank card (Q1413904)/payment terminal (Q605108)[edit]
Items involved: Q1413904Talk, Q605108Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
I noticed this problem from the German Wikipedia. Both Wikidata objects are about credit card terminals and/ or point of sale-terminals but I'm not sure what the difference between these two objects is. --Soluvo (talk) 08:17, 25 September 2018 (UTC)
|
October 2018[edit]
free trade agreement (Q3536928)/free trade area (Q5335686)[edit]
Items involved: Q3536928Talk, Q5335686Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
The Page about Free Trage Agreements/Free Trade Areas are inconsistent in e.g. the German Wikipedia (which only knows FT-Agreements) and the englisch Wiki (which only knows FT-Areas). The Problem is that you cannot link Q3536928 to the englisch Article, because it is already used in Q5335686 .--2001:16B8:2064:E000:7840:9D94:CCF9:F350 14:42, 8 October 2018 (UTC) |
National Defence University of Warsaw (Q414316)/War Studies University (Q27061984)[edit]
Items involved: Q414316Talk, Q27061984Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Der deutsche Wikipedia-Artikel Akademie der Kriegskunst (Warschau) gehört eigentlich zu beiden Objekten.Wie soll in einem solchen Fall verfahren werden? --Rita2008 (talk) 17:10, 12 October 2018 (UTC) |
fast attack craft (Q719226)/e-boat (Q11215470)/torpedo boat (Q324233)/motor torpedo boat (Q1630695)/torpedo-boat destroyer (Q16220775)[edit]
Items involved: Q719226Talk, Q11215470Talk, Q324233Talk, Q1630695Talk, Q16220775Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
This is a tangled mess of conflicts mostly created by inconsistent naming in different languages.
How can this be untangled? /ℇsquilo 10:53, 19 October 2018 (UTC) |
The Settlers III (Q2579674)/The Settlers (Q1163239)[edit]
Items involved: Q2579674Talk, Q1163239Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
English (and some other language wikipedias) have The Settlers III as an independent article. On German Wikipedia, all Settlers games are handled in the main "Die Siedler" article with extensive subsections. Pointing to the German series article fails for the obvious reason that the English series article already points to that as it's German counterpart. Pointing to a subsection is apparently not possible using Wikidata as it complains about the very same duplication problem. tl;dr In English Wikipedia there's The Settlers and The Settlers III, in German Wikipedia there's only Die Siedler and Die Siedler#Die Siedler III, but no standalone article. --Mastacheata (talk) 21:30, 26 October 2018 (UTC) |
November 2018[edit]
Q488521/Q16174582[edit]
Items involved: Q488521Talk, Q16174582Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
The page you have chosen is already associated to an item on our central data repository. Please confirm that the pages shown below are the ones that you want to link to this page. --> I hereby confirm that I wish to link these pages to each other. :) --Enyavar (talk) 16:05, 5 November 2018 (UTC)
|
Q58198703/Q82306[edit]
Items involved: Q58198703Talk, Q82306Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
There are articles called "Asia Bibi", and there are articles called "Asia Bibi (...) case". However, all have the case against the person as their main subject. There should be no split. See here. Apdency (talk) 22:22, 8 November 2018 (UTC) |
federation (Q43702)[edit]
Items involved: Q43702Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Maybe it's just the terminology or the descriptions that are a mix, maybe it's the sitelinks. Somehow one would want to differentiate between a federal state and a federation of independent states. ----- Jura 17:27, 11 November 2018 (UTC) |
crime novel (Q208505)/crime fiction (Q19842222)[edit]
Items involved: Q208505Talk, Q19842222Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Some languages of Wikipedia use one item, and others use the other item, but both item are same (or very similar). Only two languages (fr, nl) have pages of Wikipedia in both items. --Davidhs0 (talk) 16:51, 12 November 2018 (UTC) |
Wikimedia main page (Q5296)[edit]
Items involved: Q5296Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
Please se Talk:Q5296#Sl.wiktionary. Thanks, --Janezdrilc (talk) 21:55, 16 November 2018 (UTC) |
topic–comment (Q933845)/topic (Q200801)[edit]
Items involved: Q933845Talk, Q200801Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
topic–comment (Q933845) and topic (Q200801) are the same item. – The preceding unsigned comment was added by RetusLee (talk • contribs) at 08:21, 21 November 2018 (UTC).
|
Category:Ship framing (Q8737608)/Category:Shipbuilding (Q8737528)/Category:Watercraft components (Q8697145)[edit]
Items involved: Q8737608Talk, Q8737528Talk, Q8697145Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
--Dvorapa (talk) 00:45, 28 November 2018 (UTC)
|
Myeong-dong (Q484407)/Q17216309[edit]
Items involved: Q484407Talk, Q17216309Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
Needs zhwiki and jawiki contributors to fix. --Liuxinyu970226 (talk) 09:35, 30 November 2018 (UTC)
|
December 2018[edit]
Treaties categories[edit]
Items involved: Q6469367Talk, Q32684510Talk | Status: in doubt | ||
--Epìdosis 23:18, 12 December 2018 (UTC)
|
Night clubs[edit]
Items involved: Q7215658Talk, Q8934319Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
JoJo's Venture (Q3179359)/JoJo's Bizarre Adventure (Q2757037)[edit]
Items involved: Q3179359Talk, Q2757037Talk | Status: not resolved | ||
In French, the 1998 (original release, 1999 was the updated release, so JoJo's Bizarre Adventure (Q2757037) is incorrect there) game is listed as being associated with JoJo's Venture (Q3179359). In English and most other languages, the game is represented as JoJo's Bizarre Adventure (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure (Q2757037)). The [1](French wiki article) is listed as the respective wiki article for JoJo's Bizarre Adventure (Q2757037), which isn't entirely incorrect (Heritage for the Future is an updated version of JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, per the intro paragraph of the English wiki page). I'm not sure exactly how this should be resolved, but I planned to suggest merging JoJo's Venture (Q3179359) into JoJo's Bizarre Adventure (Q2757037) after changing what the French wiki article points to. Given that the French Wikipedia has separate articles for the original/updated game whereas the other Wikipedias have only one article, I think the French Wikipedia would probably need modifying. --Nicereddy (talk) 22:09, 29 December 2018 (UTC) |