Wikidata:Property proposal/disputed by

From Wikidata
Jump to navigation Jump to search

disputed By[edit]

Originally proposed at Wikidata:Property proposal/Organization

Descriptionthe concept described by the item is criticized by other item(s)
Data typeItem
Domainitem
Example 1capitalism (Q6206) disputed by Marxism (Q7264)
Example 2cognitivism (Q23382) disputed by embodied cognition (Q1335050)
Example 3Oralism (Q1411862) disputed by Edward Miner Gallaudet (Q1293026)
Planned useCan be used for modeling academic or political discourses or disputes.
See alsostatement disputed by (P1310) ← Similar, but for statements. approved by (P790) ← Similar to an opposite. However, the examples at least are focused on institutions formally endorsing or classifying things.

Motivation[edit]

I would like to model how academic and political fields related to each other. Many ideas come from opposition towards a (then-dominant) paradigm. I also consider it as important for covering relevant knowledge. E.g. One of the most important properties of the idea known as "Marxism" can be seen as that it is an explicit criticism of another idea, "capitalism". "Free Software" is an alternative and opposition to software with proprietary licensing etc. Without such information, the practical, political or historical relevance of the topics is hard to understand. -- Simulo (talk) 14:23, 29 September 2019 (UTC)

Note: Feel free to suggest a different name, if you think it does not match the intended use or if it clashes with other properties. I e.g. considered "argues against" and "criticizes", too. Simulo (talk) 16:27, 29 September 2019 (UTC)

Discussion[edit]

I never suggested a property before, so there might be missing info in the template (was unsure about the "domain") or misinterpretations of the appropriate procedure. -- Simulo (talk) 14:29, 29 September 2019 (UTC)