Wikidata:Mismatched reference notification input

From Wikidata
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Description[edit]

As part of our work on data quality, and how we can make sure that data and references match, we have been working on a new notification to make it less likely for data to be changed without updating the reference.

Screenshot of the first version of the mismatched reference notification

The idea is to inform the editors when they edit an existing statement where there is already a reference, and change the value without changing the reference. This will appear as a notification icon, similar to constraints, once the statement is saved. In the next version of the feature, the editor will have the possibility to update the reference or to mark the notification as irrelevant, if changing the value without changing the reference was made on purpose (for example, to fix a typo or a mistake).

In the first version of the feature, the notification is temporary and focused on the editor who made the change: the editor who made the change will see it appear when they saved their edit, but if they reload the page, the notification will be gone. Other users also won’t be able to see it. A possible next step would be making the warning persistent, hence visible for other users.

How to try the feature?[edit]

The feature is enabled on https://test.wikidata.org. You can test it for example on this Item by changing the value of the statement P121 (date of foundation or creation). You don’t need to log in to edit and see the notification.

What are the next steps?[edit]

You are very welcome to try the feature on test.wikidata.org and give feedback until the end of January. Unless there is a major issue preventing us to deploy the feature, it will be made available on wikidata.org for all users.

In order to understand your needs and workflows better, we would love to get your feedback on the talk page. You will find a few questions to guide you if needed.

Give feedback

More information[edit]