Topic on User talk:Harmonia Amanda

privacy of underage skaters

Sorry, why did you delete Anna La Porta competitions?

I added again, you can see that she did them in the ISU ufficial results:

http://www.isuresults.com/bios/isufs00103160.htm

There were several different cases. I deleted a wrong link, pointing to an illustrating distinction. You actually tried to make the item about the skating competition but before your intervention it was not about that. I cleaned up the item and created new entities for the figure skating competition in general and the 2019 edition in particular.

For this case (I deleted instead of just changing) and the other two competitions I deleted, it's because the links where to the generic competition instead of the specific discipline. And for now the policy on Wikidata is to not create entries for junior competitions, except for the ISU Grand Prix, World championships and Youth Olympics. This policy was made to protect the privacy of underage living people. We can't add results of only part the skaters, and that means creating entries for all the skaters for every competition. For the big international ones, that makes sense, due to the media coverage and availability of the information. For smaller competitions, it's making highly visible/easy to retrieve what could be considered as private information of minors.

Thanks for you answer, are you sure that is for everyone?

Could you please tell me why for ex. HAlloween cup is on alexia Paganini page?

Q42706893

Can I add the swiss national championship or not, in Alexia page there is and Anna was twice silver in 2019 and 2020 in junior

Sorry, I'll try to make it clearer. We enter the scores:

• For juniors: Grand Prix ISU (qualifications and finale), Junior Worlds, Youth Olympics
• For seniors: national championships, international competitions.

Because Alexia Paganini competed as a senior, not a junior, at the Halloween Cup. We do enter the scores of seniors, even if they are underage, for national championships and international competitions only.

Thanks Amanda, now is clear.

Have a good day

Have a good day too, and do not hesitate to ask other questions if you have them! I'm always happy to help and I'm always happy when talking about figure skating :)